« Blogging On | Main | Better read than dread: why your company needs a blog policy »
October 19, 2005
How do you pitch a blogger? Very carefully
The BlogOn Social Media Summit had a fascinating session yesterday on the question of how to make public relations pitches to bloggers. Representing the pitchers was Jeremy Pepper; representing the pitchees was Andrew Carton of the Treonauts blog. Moderating was Cathy Brooks of the PR agency of Porter Novelli.
Hanging over the session was an angry post on the whole topic the day before by Jeff Jarvis. He was on a panel and noted that other illustrious speakers were planned, but then wrote:
I also see panels such as this: "Pitching to Social Media ... How do you pitch to bloggers when most spurn overt attempts to influence them? It’s a whole new PR ballgame and you need a new playbook to get in the game."
Makes my skin crawl. Businesses think they can exploit blogs. But I want to tell blogs to exploit businesses instead: Get what you want out of them. Get advertising money out of them, if you want. Or attention. Or peace and quiet. If a PR company calls you, tell them to have their ad buyers call instead. This is why I generallly won’t do panels at events for PR people. No offense. But there’s nothing in it for us. They want free publicity from us. They want to piggyback on our trust. Well, then, buy an ad.
Tuesday, Jeremy began by saying he "100% supports pitching bloggers," but noted he’s been on the receiving end of clumsy pitches himself. Although his blog is about public relations, he’s been pitched to blog about music sites, for example. He attributed such clunky attempts to junior PR staff working without oversight.
Andrew doesn't mind being pitched but when he asked a flack why public relations people were approaching him, rather than marketing reps, he was told that because he wasn’t being paid to write about Treos, he fell under the purview of public relations.
That line of demarcation is vanishing. A blogger in the audience said a flack had pitched her a story and simultaneously asked about buying an ad. The blogger needed the ad revenue but didn’t want it to influence her decision whether to write about the product. Her solution is to keep the traditional news publishing model in mind, with its church and state separation of editorial and advertising functions. It’s harder to do of course, when the editor is also the ad salesman.
Andrew, who makes a respectable sum of money from his blog, believes blog readers implicitly understand that bloggers make money from advertising and respect that.
Aside from the ethics, practical tips emerged for pitching bloggers:
- Read the blog before pitching it!
- Make the pitch short and low-key
- Provide a link & contact information for an expert
P.S. Here’s a New York miracle: I got out of the cab at the Copacabana Tuesday, schlepping luggage, laptop, swag bag and purse. I went to the coat check to drop them off. I had left the laptop in the cab! I ran back outside. The doorman spotted the cab, which had turned around! The cabbie stopped! The laptop was rescued! New York is full of nice people.
Technorati tags:
Posted by Laurie Mayers at October 19, 2005 10:49 AM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.mslpr.com/blogworks/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/351
Comments
But there’s nothing in it for us.
Like I said yesterday, I guess information, products for reviews, access are akin to nothing for Jarvis.
It made no sense when he wrote it, it made no sense when we discussed it, and it will likely make no sense how a former journalist can write that blogs are about trust, but buy an ad if you want to influence me. Huh?!?
But, I always have found NY'ers to be very nice and helpful, despite the stereotypes. Great to meet you!
Posted by: Jeremy Pepper at October 19, 2005 04:53 PM
Exactly, the traditional relationship of PR to publisher is a valid model for the blogosphere. The reporter / blogger gets access & information, which s/he needs -- and is free to reject -- and the PR practitioner spreads the word for his/her client.
It was great to meet you, too!
Posted by: Laurie Mayers at October 20, 2005 04:26 PM


