« Wal-Mart hits, Humane Society's misses opportunity | Main | Global PR Week 2.0 starts today »

September 16, 2005

Good Blog, Bad BlogFirestorm over Firehouse blog

Chrysler Group launched a blog this week for journalists only. TheFirehouse.biz blog is named after the extremely popular (can you say "free music, hot food and open bar"?) media-only party it hosts for several days during the North American International Auto Show at a Detroit firehouse. Its editorial director is Ed Garsten, formerly of CNN, The Associated Press and, most recently, The Detroit News’ GM beat.

The problem came when some bloggers who applied for admission were rejected. They got this e-mail (I got one, too):

Thanks for your interest in TheFirehouse.biz, the Chrysler Group's media-only blog. We will issue media registration rights to members of the working press only. A member of the working press is one who is paid as an employee, freelancer who regularly contributes, or representative of a known and established media organization (newspaper, magazine, television, radio, etc.) If you would like to resubmit your registration, we would be happy to reconsider it.

Note the list of legit media doesn’t include web sites or blogs, although Garsten said: "Yes, we do consider some blogs legitimate journalism and have granted access to those who regularly cover the auto industry." He also promises that "No one will ever be banished for negative comments or negative stories."

Adrants, B.L. Ochman, Diva Marketing and Chris Houchens were not kind. Adrants called it "completely illogical and non-sensical," and Houchens lumped it in with the notorious fake blogs by Captain Morgan and Juicy Fruit. (On the other hand, Topaz Partners gave Chrysler credit for focusing its first blogging effort on a selected audience.)

Chrysler Communications VP Jason Vines answered on The Firehouse.biz:

The Firehouse.biz is a chance to have an open dialogue with journalists who report on our company and the industry and who literally bombard us with their comments, questions, rants and bad jokes. Unlike our media site, which is a one-way deal, The Firehouse.biz is a two-way street that goes off the page of the press release and allows reporters to vent, probe, attack, while we get a chance to respond on the fly from anywhere in the world and maybe hose down some rumors, or douse the idiotic rants from someone who is uninformed.

In fact, a blog might be the right tool to accomplish those tasks. But surely you’re inviting trouble when you publicize your blog and link to it from your media site, then restrict access so severely.

Vines, whose former jobs include standup comedian and top flack for Ford executive Jac Nasser, also notes on the blog that:

Everything we say in TheFirehouse.biz is on the record, so you’re all free to use anything posted by me or our executives in a story or broadcast. All I ask in return from the media, is please, no X-rated stuff. I get enough of that in my email box … and I’m trying to get my mother to stop. Also … in the spirit of keeping things open and honest, we’d prefer you use your real names when you submit a comment or question. You can use a screen name if you like, but then how would I know to leave you off the list for the holiday party? Finally, we’ll never edit your submissions, but we’ll only post those that stay on the topic and agree with everything I say. That last part’s not true.

So far, only three journalists have left comments on The Firehouse.biz. But there are already seven links to it on Technorati.

Posted by Laurie Mayers at September 16, 2005 02:33 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.mslpr.com/blogworks/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/257

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Firestorm over Firehouse blog:

» Chysler's Media Only Blog: A Culture Thing from Diva Marketing (Blog)
Here's the back-story about the Chrysler Group Media Blog, The Firehouse.biz, direct from mysource at Chrysler who has asked to remain anonymous. Chrysler's strategy was to create a blog to support their online press only site. As mysource pointed out,... [Read More]

Tracked on September 16, 2005 04:56 PM

» Chrysler's Firehouse: Corporate Blog Gone Wrong from Influential Interactive Marketing
Perhaps aiming to avoid the mistakes of Dell in ignoring Jeff Jarvis' blog comments and experience, Chrysler PR chief Jason Vines has taken a wide swing in the opposite direction, lashing out at Steve Hall of Adrants in response to [Read More]

Tracked on September 19, 2005 04:46 PM

» Clueless about the flap over DaimlerChrysler's Firehouse media blog... but not wrong from BlogWrite for CEOs
I seem to be a couple of steps behind these days. But that's the way it goes when you've got your head buried in writing a book. I was doing a Technorati search on something tonight when I realized that [Read More]

Tracked on October 5, 2005 08:54 PM

Comments

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)

To protect against spam, off-topic and abusive comments, all comments are reviewed before being posted to the blog.